spacer
spacer
 eWombat Search

Subscribe to our newsletter

* indicates required
spacer
   Get ASX price
spacer
  Accounting Services Home   Financial Planning Home   Lending Services Home
  Latest Financial Planning News
Business confidence hits 5-month high: NAB
New Year resolutions, New Year strategies
How will downsizer contributions work for SMSFs?
Where Australia is at. Our leading indicators.
‘Read the tea leaves,’ brace for cryptocurrency regulation, advisers told
Power of retiree super dollars
Beyond share prices
Financial advice is the leading trigger to review insurance inside Super
Opinion – 2018 to be the year of the machine
Rising risks to the status quo
UPDATE: Australia's vital statistics
As share prices rise, the risk-return trade-off gets tricky
Technical expert flags top 3 traps with CGT relief
Become a better investor through your holiday reading
Australia's vital statistics
Made in Albania? How globalisation is creating challenges for Chinese policymakers
Our Advent calendar for 2017
For the young it a question of engagement
Address Under-insurance at Personal Finance Level - Global study
Realism vs reality - working part-time as retirees
SMSFs warned on ‘ticking time bomb’ with outdated deeds
Statutory wills are underutilised in estate planning
Resources on our site to help you, your family and your friends.
Calls to Review ASIC's Definition of Lapse Insurance
Paperwork bungles lead to $38k in payments
Self-employed? Don't miss out on super
Australian Dietary Guidelines and healthy eating chart (PDF)
Big concessions looking likely for transfer balance limit: ATO
Raft of superannuation measures enter Parliament
US Fed policy: Normalisation begins
What the gig economy may mean for your super
Powerful Budgeting, cash flow and Super Tools available on our site.
Australia's leading causes of death - ABS
Government introduces first home scheme laws
Are young investors wasting their youth?
ATO granted super enforcement powers
The great Australian (retiree) dream
ATO to release further guidance on reserves
A real-world benchmark for SMSF performance
How is your super going, ready for retirement?
Our 'hardest' SMSF tasks
Lack of literacy promotes unrealistic goals
Young investors: Time is on your side
Is your SMSF retirement-ready?
Key Economic Indicators, 2017 - updated
Investors acting their age
ATO locks in details, addresses panic on real-time reporting
Government ‘undermines’ tax system in new moves on property expenses
Multiple super accounts in a 'gig' society
Why Australian retirees aren't happy and what we can do about it
Doing a budget is a good idea but ....
Technical expert flags estate planning strategies for 2017-18
Government to shut down salary sacrifice loophole
Items that heat up your depreciation deductions
‘Tens of thousands’ of SMSFs at risk with ECPI
Do’s and don’ts of estate planning
LISTO to help boost women’s super
Smart ways to stretch retirement money
Low economic growth likely for years
Recorded Crime - Offenders, 2015-16
Adequacy of savings still a concern among Australians
‘Bank-like heists’ make way for new wave of cyber crime
Give your children a saving and investing edge - for life
Women still in the dark about finances
Lessons learnt - often the hard way
Australian population figures
ATO poised to ramp up focus on key compliance area
Benefit payments rise dramatically ahead of July 1 super changes
There's no magic pudding when it comes to super
ATO guidance provides clarity on death benefit confusion
Beyond super: Our other personal investment market
The three core pillars of this year's budget
Federal Budget - 2017-18 - Overview
Federal Budget - 2017-18 - Budget documents
Global economy synchronised and thriving
Life's financial turning points: good and not-so-good
2011 Census - what was the make up of your area?
ATO set to release guidance targeted for SMSF clients
More withdrawals from 'the bank of mum and dad'
Tax headache relief: Here’s more help with pension assets changes
Most Aussies shun super advice
Australia in a nutshell
ATO finalises guidance on transfer balance cap
Fit for purpose? The super story so far...
SMSFs urged to review segregation clauses in trust deed
Big insto addresses CGT misconceptions
Dollar-cost averaging for millennial investors
Calls for calm over pending CGT amendments
Almost the world's best for retirees
ATO reports on top contravention areas for SMSFs
What recent retirees can teach pre-retirees
Deloitte points to ‘red flag’ SMSF patterns
Save early, save often
Government pushes forward with multinational tax measures
Jump-start your retirement savings
Government urged to rectify ‘legislative shortcoming’ with CGT relief
Some financial terms explained
Areas of key focus for SMSFs in 2017.
Powerful Superannuation modelling tools available on our site.
Your New Year reading: beyond John Grisham
What a long-term view of the market can teach investors
CGT confusion seeing unnecessary sell-offs
‘Devastating’ property investments hitting SMSFs
Asset valuation crackdown imminent for SMSFs
New Year (investment) resolutions
Trump stimulus to boost global markets
Female advice customers on the rise
Retirement costs outpace rise in CPI
ATO set to scrutinise CGT relief claims
Investor habits: The good, the bad and the ugly
Keeping finances in the family
The inter-generational financial squeeze
Merry Christmas for 2016, a Happy New Year and a prosperous 2017.
ATO set to clamp down on range of super issues
SME retirement plans in jeopardy, research finds
SMSFs show restraint in hot residential market
Investment's building blocks - always worth reinforcing
Warnings issued on traps with CGT transitional rules
Meet SMSFs' early and late arrivals
Beware, the ATO is on the hunt for lifestyle assets
'Brexit means Brexit' means what?
SMSFs tipped to be hardest hit by pension changes
SMSF assets hit record, but funds still hoarding cash
Markets caution advised as economic bubbles loom
Stretching retirement income
Some financial terms explained
Market Update – September 2016
Checking in on our 2016 economic outlook - and looking ahead
Making a fairer and more sustainable Superannuation System
Going undercover
‘Winners and Losers’ from new super proposals
The gymnastics of keeping your portfolio balanced
Market Update – August 2016
Stop!! Don't do a paper Budget, use our online budgeting tools instead.
Advisers the key to retirement stability, research shows
The toughest tasks for self-managed super
Lawyer warns on ‘adverse’ death taxes with insurance
Don't get distracted by super changes
A savings mirage?
Market Update - July 2016
The three biggest economic issues likely to affect markets in 2016
SMSFs warned on looming property ‘tough times’
Diversification counts when uncertainty beckons
Strong economic data stablises markets
Starting a super pension in 2016-17?
Market Update - June 2016
ATO extends looming SuperStream deadline
ATO's deadline for review non-arm's length LRBAs extended
A paradoxical relationship: The self-employed and super
Fresh SMSF documentation warnings surface
Making investing a family affair
Super and divorce: a personal finance issue
Market Update - May 2016
ASIC flags SMSF investors in scam risk
Older, greyer and still working
Working and contributing to super past 65
The pitfalls of part-year pensions
Replenishing SMSF memberships
Budget will hit 15% of SMSFs
The insidious side of low interest rates
Market Update - April 2016
Budget 2016-17
Do investment principles stand test of time?
Estate Planning - early inheritance
US economy will bend, not break
A detailed look at the ATO’s new LRBA guidance
Defying life's blueprint
ATO continuing lodgement crackdown
Another twist on the gender savings gap
Market Update – March 2016
Going solo
Use our online budgeting tools to help plan your future.
Age Pension means-test prevents rational decision-making
Changing times for super collectables
Preservation Age Rule
Why investing for retirement isn't just about super
Possible tax benefits through early inheritance
Market Update - 29th February 2016
Mortgages, personal debt and retirement
Cost of retirement continues to climb
Personal finance goes 'viral'
ATO warns on poor asset records causing SMSF breaches
When is an unallocated contribution account a reserve?
Market Update – 31st January 2016
Australians still need better retirement planning
What to expect from investment markets in 2016 and beyond
‘Irrational fear’ impacting SMSF longevity risk: CSIRO
Tax scam reaps hundreds of thousands
Morrison signals direction of super tax changes
Market Update – 31st December 2015
Should we expect stormy skies or sunshine in 2016?
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year 2015
There's no one-size-fits-all retirement income
Market Update – 30th November 2015
Diversifying and cutting costs with ETFs
Why the ATO’s new powers make SMSF compliance more important than ever
'Unretiring' retirees
The detrimental impact of poor SMSF record-keeping
Counting the cost of 'grey' divorce
Combining total-return investing with realistic investment expectations
Market Update – 31st October 2015
Another telling reminder for SMSF trustees
The demand for global infrastructure
Death in paradise – or your SMSF
Elderly exploited for assets
Intergenerational challenges for retirement saving
Help achieve your investment goals with dynamic asset allocation
Death benefits – navigating the minefield
The Power of Budgeting
Strategy over structure
Market Update – 3oth September 2015
Jump retirement hurdles with a coach
Preparing for the time of your life
SMSF and limited resource borrowing – a warning
External partnerships and the in-house asset rules
Take a closer look at SMSF age demographics
Avoiding tax consequences with the related-party rules
Focusing on after-tax returns
Market Update – 31st August 2015
The gender gap in retirement
Why popularity of ETFs is surging among SMSFs
Clearing up confusion about accessing super.
Good (investor) behaviour
Five reasons the RBA will likely cut rates again
Market Update – 31st July 2015
What the ATO is keeping an eye on
Through life and death
Why astute investors are a little like astute kayakers.
Your first SMSF portfolio
Market Update - June 2015
Money-smart ageing
A new (financial) year’s resolution for your SMSF
What’s ahead for US interest rates?
Super: Looking to June 30 and beyond
End of year tips for SMSFs
Reminders and Tax Strategies for SMSFs pre-year end
Market Update – May 2015
A Super Loan for all reasons
SMSF trustee penalties going up
Contraventions rife among non-advised SMSF trustees
Dealing with investor uncertainty
Reserve bank gives the economy a lift
Retirement planning: the gap between intention and reality
Market Update – April 2015
Making a smooth transition
Budget 2015 - some professional opinions
Australian Government - Budget 2015
Budget 2015 - some professional opinions
Australian Government - Budget 2015
What does the ATO want from you?
Making sense of the new excess contribution rules
Achieving a comfortable retirement
Greying, working and contributing
Simple-yet-smart investment housekeeping
Market Update – March 2015
Is off-the-plan on the money?
Should I take my super as a lump sum or not?
Do you have a key person in your business?
Tips for success in a competitive job market
All you need to know about buying at auction
To sell or not to sell?
Saving in a material world
Tax headache relief: Here’s more help with pension assets changes

Let’s take a look at a practical example of how the new capital gains tax relief will operate for pension assets.



       


 


In particular, let’s focus on unsegregated pension assets, for three reasons. Firstly, unsegregated pension assets receive a different CGT relief than segregated pension assets. Secondly, unsegregated pension assets are more common than segregated pension assets. And finally, the CGT relief for unsegregated pension assets is more complex than that for segregated pension assets.


Background


From July 1, 2017, major changes will take effect with respect to the taxation of superannuation. One change is that fund assets supporting transition-to-retirement income streams will no longer be eligible for an income-tax exemption. Another change is the introduction of the transfer balance cap, which (at the risk of oversimplifying things) limits the amount capital that can be used to commence a pension to $1.6 million). As a relief, certain legislation has been introduced that, as stated in (s 294-100), is designed to provide temporary relief from certain capital gains that might arise as a result of individuals complying with the following legislative changes:


The introduction of a transfer balance cap (as a result of Schedule 1 to the Treasury Laws Amendment (Fair and Sustainable Superannuation) Act 2016)
The exclusion of transition-to-retirement income streams (and similar income streams) from being superannuation income streams in the retirement phase (as a result of Schedule 8 to that Act).


A practical example


Assume that on November 9, 2016, (i.e., the start of what the legislation defines as the ‘pre-commencement period’), a sole member fund called the Sample Superannuation Fund had a total of $2.1 million in assets, of which $1.8 million was supporting pensions and $300,000 was not. Further assume that the fund did not have any ‘segregated current pension assets’ or ‘segregated non-current pension assets’ (i.e., the fund was using the proportionate method – also known as the actuarial method – to calculate and obtain its income-tax exemption).


Assume that the fund has the following assets:


  • $400,000 in cash
  • 5000 shares in BigCompany Ltd, which were purchased as a parcel in 2012 for $40 each (assume that shares are now worth $150 each, that is, a total of $750,000)
  • 1000 more shares in BigCompany Ltd, which were purchased as a parcel in 2014 for $70 each (similar to the above, these shares are worth $150,000)
  • real estate, purchased in 2003 for $200,000, which is now worth $800,000.

Note that the CGT relief for unsegregated pension assets results in a cost base reset as at ‘immediately before 1 July 2017’. This is different than CGT relief for segregated pension assets, where there is the ability to choose (within certain parameters) when the cost base reset occurs. Accordingly, let’s assume that the current market values of the assets as set out above will continue to be the market values as at immediately before July 1, 2017.


Also, note that the operative provisions (i.e., ss 294-115 and 294-120) do not expressly require than an asset be commuted out of a pension in order to obtain the relief. Although the ATO disagreed with this in the draft version of Law Companion Guideline LCG 2016/8 (see paragraph 21), it changed its position in the final version (see example 4 for an illustrative example of this).


Next, let’s say the fund partially commutes $200,000 of the pension and internally rolls the resulting lump sum back into accumulation.  


Subject to certain other assumptions – for example, that the fund is at all relevant times a complying superannuation fund, etc. – the fund will have the ability to choose to apply the CGT relief to some or all of its assets. Consistent with ATO Taxation Determination TD 33, the fund chooses to apply the relief to 700 of the shares in BigCompany Ltd that were purchased in 2012, and to the real estate.


Accordingly, the following ‘notional’ net capital gain arises:


  • 700 x ($150-$40), that is, $77,000, less a one-third discount, that is, $51,333.
  • $800,000-$200,000, that is, $600,000, less a one-third discount, that is, $400,000 (I assume that the grandfathered rules regarding trading stock do not apply).

Accordingly, the total ‘notional’ net capital gain is $451,333. In order to then derive the ‘deferred notional gain’, it is necessary to multiple this figure by the proportion that the actuary advises is not in pension mode. More specifically, assume the fund’s actuary advises that in respect of the 2017 financial year, the proportion calculated by dividing the fund’s ‘Average value of current pension liabilities’ by the fund’s ‘Average value of superannuation liabilities’ is 60 per cent. Therefore, to then derive the ‘deferred notional gain’ it is necessary to multiply $451,333 by 40 per cent (100 per cent minus 60 per cent). In light of this, the deferred notional gain is $180,533.


Assuming the 700 shares in BigCompany Ltd and the real estate are both disposed of in the same financial year (for example, the 2019 financial year), the net capital gain of the fund is increased by $180,533. Similarly, the cost base of the 700 shares is treated as being 700 x $150 and the cost base of the real estate is treated as being $800,000.


Some traps


Choosing the relief will reset the 12-month period when it comes to eligible for being a discount capital gain. In short, that means relief probably should not be chosen for some assets that will be sold during the 2018 financial year. Consider the following example of when it is detrimental to a fund to choose the relief: An asset was purchased during the 2016 financial year for $120. On June 30, 2017, its market value is $130. It will be sold on January 1, 2018, for $160. If relief is chosen, this will give rise to $4.50 of tax (i.e., [$160–$130]*15%). However, if relief is not chosen, this will give rise to $4 of tax ([$160–$120] x 10%).


Naturally, remember the role of pt IVA (i.e., the general anti-avoidance provision). As the ATO states in Law Companion Guideline LCG 2016/D:


Broadly speaking, schemes which do no more than that which is necessary to comply with those reforms will not be the subject of determinations under Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (ITAA 1936) (Part IVA). Schemes which abuse the relief are another matter …


The kinds of arrangements that the commissioner will scrutinise carefully with a view to determining whether Part IVA applies will exhibit the following features:


  • They place the taxpayer in a position to make the choice
  • They go further than is necessary to provide temporary relief from CGT because members comply with the reforms, and They exhibit contrivance of manner, a lack of correspondence of form with substance, or other matters relevant under section 177D of the ITAA 1936, that point to the purpose of avoiding tax.

I suspect that the largest pt IVA concerns will occur for account-based pensions, not transition-to-retirement income streams, particularly those eligible for the segregated pension asset CGT relief, not the relief described in this article. 


For full details, see subdiv 294 B of the Income Tax (Transitional Provisions) Act 1997, which was inserted by the Treasury Laws Amendment (Fair and Sustainable Superannuation) Act 2016. Also instructive is the ATO’s Law Companion Guideline LCG 2016/8.


This article is for general information only and should not be relied upon without first seeking advice from an appropriately qualified professional.


 


BY:  Bryce Figot
April 12, 2017
professionalplanner.com.au


Site by PlannerWeb

227 Hutt Street, Adelaide SA 5000 | PHONE:(08) 8272 6833 | FAX:(08) 8227 2608

GWM Adviser Services Limited is only responsible for advice provided by EFC Financial Services Pty Ltd under the terms of Authorisation (Authorised Representative) of the Licensee.

  I have read & agree to the terms described above